Substituting a 190 for the 200 rear tire

Ducati Forum

Help Support Ducati Forum:

I have fitted a diablo supercorsa sp 190 as that is all they had available whilst I was on a bike holiday in spain. I had totally destroyed my 200 rear tyre (see my post in panigale pics) I was riding hard with the 200 and just as hard with the 190. I noticed no change in handling or ride height and the traction light was lighting only when I would expect it to. So the only difference I have found is that you can ride right to the outside of the 190 easier than the 200. And a 190 will be easier to find when a replacement is required.
 
Really?

Implicitly this means the traction control takes into account speed and factors in tire growth, wear, lean angle and fork/shock compression, all of which impact the effective diameter of the tires.

So let's look at some numbers to put things in perspective.

The tread depth of the 200/55 Pirelli Supercorsa is 4.75mm. If traction control is indeed sensitive enough to be significantly affected by a 5.5mm reduction in tire size, does that mean that it adjusts for tire wear or is it optimized for some very specific amount of wear and when tires don't have this amount of wear, traction control doesn't work properly?

Tires also tend to grow over time due to pressure and heat cycling. 3-8% growth is not unreasonable to expect. Does traction control adjust for tire growth?

For a 200/55 tire the maximum diameter of the tire is 25.66" (straight up and down), while the minimum dimater is 20.5" (full lean). This means when leaned over a speed sensor based on rear wheel revolutions reads a higher speed than when the bike is upright. The vast majority of operational diameters between a 190/55 and 200/55 is going to fall within the diameter range that you might see using a 200/55. Rather than rely on tire circumference as a parameter for traction control, I would expect it to use a 3 dimensional accelerometer to determine how leaned over a bike was and to use this to calculate the acceptable speed differential between the front and rear wheel before traction control takes effect. Speed differential alone between the front and rear wheels is not enough to make an effective traction control, since tire diameter varies significantly from full lean to upright.

While fork/shock compression and extension is not the same as ride height adjustment it can have some of the same geometry impacts. Assuming 3" travel, you get 76.2mm in range from full extension to full compression for the suspension. 5.5mm is relatively insignificant compared with the impact suspension travel can have on geometry. Unless traction control is somehow figuring out suspension compression and extension it is unlikely traction control is going to be significantly impacted by a 5.5mm ride height change.

Given the preceding it is very unlikely that traction control is sensitive enough to be significantly thrown off by going to a 190/55 tire. There are too many other factors which have much larger effects than this change for this change to be significant.

From a complete neutrals position - I remember a UK mag (either Performance Bike or Superbike) who had a track shoot out with 1198, S1RR and RSV4 and they put control tires on the lot and it immediately relegated the Duc to 3rd place as the TC couldn't function 100% efficiently with the non - Pirellis. So I've always believed the type and size of tire can throw a bikes electronics for a loop - not that I would ever notice but someone who can wring its neck might.
 
Don't do it. Besides the issues of screwing up the TC, (it IS sensitive enough to detect the size change) lower rear ride height, (5.5 mm is a big change in ride height that WILL affect handling) and geometry, it is also the perfect reason for Ducati (both the dealer and DNA) to void your warranty. The bike was designed around a 200 rear and performs best with it.

Just an FYI on the warranty issue: US law generally doesn't allow a manufacturer to "void" a warranty. They may be able to refuse to cover a repair because it arises due to abuse, for example, but voiding the entire warranty for putting a different tire on it would probably be illegal.
 
Changing from a 200/55 to a 190/55 decreases the ride height of the bike by 5.5mm. and a 1.7% decrease in rolling circumference.

My brain just imploded.

Two 17" rims, with tyres both 55mm profile, have a 5.5mm difference in ride height?
 
My brain just imploded.

Two 17" rims, with tyres both 55mm profile, have a 5.5mm difference in ride height?

55 is not a profile dimension in mm, it is an aspect ratio of 55%. To get the sidewall height, you multiply the aspect ratio by the width of the tire.

190mm width * .55 = 104.5mm sidewall height
200mm width * .55 = 110.0mm sidewall height
110.0-104.5=5.5mm sidewall height difference.
 

Register CTA

Register on Ducati Forum! This sidebar will go away, and you will see fewer ads.

Recent Discussions

Back
Top