Love the Panigale to bits, but I gotta say, even though it's an ugly son of a b*tch, the Desmo gets my vote.
Only due to the fact though the Desmo is the closest thing you will own to a Moto GP bike. The Superleggera is just another version (5th) of a an already awesome bike.
I think somebody else on here elsewhere summed it up in a conversation about the Surperleggera. Ducati are selling to the Apple generation i.e. iPhone3, 4, 4S, 5, 5S/ 1199, 1199ABS, 1199S, 1199R........ blah, blah, blah. It's very commercialised.
The Desmo is an incredible unique and singular machine. The Panigale Superleggera is an incredible variant!
But to actually own, afford, service, run (dare to take on track days!) and live with day to day, I will still take my 1199S (Rrrrrrrrr when it gets here!!) over both.
Can I change my vote?!?!