Honestly, I’m not a great rider probably not eve ya good rider compared to a lot of guys here, that being said the 1299 SL/FE with my tastes in mods is way more bike than I will personally ever be able to match is skills. I rode the V4 at Ducati Newport Beach quite a few times when they came out and again when the R came out. Those of you who know me definitely know cost is not a consideration on stuff but I was just never drawn to the V4.
It honestly didn’t do anything for me personally and I don’t think I would ever chose that for a platform if I had to have a 4 cylinder bike. I personally don’t think it’s leaps and bounds from an evolutionary perspective to the 99.
If I thought it’s was “the future” I would have built one but I feel the platform for me was just a different bike and not a positive departure from the 99 at least for me.
Great bikes and super smooth and fast but so is the new Honda and BMW. I do believe it’s way more expensive to go fast on the Ducati platform than it is on the competition. I think when the bike came out and we saw the rev range and power potential everyone thought that it was just going to walk away from things and it just hasn’t.
I think the other manufacturers have better platforms that are fare easier to mod, have far more factory support for racers and are less expensive to go fast on. The 99s to me are the pinnacle of Ducati development. Maybe the next gen bike will offer something different.
Intersting perspective. Having now spent time (track only really) on both the v4 and 2015 R, I find myself torn. They’re both quite good. The R feels a little more nimble (likely due to the 1” shorter wheelbase), and punchier (low end torque), and a bit less refined, but the family heritage is there.
My R has significantly higher-end components than my v4 (FGR superbike forks for example), and a little more power (205 vs 195 on the dyno), but the on-track experience isn’t night and day different between the two - I really enjoy both but probably enjoy the v4 a little more.
I had the opportunity to ride a buddy’s nicely modified v4r at COTA recently. Surprisingly, although it was very fast (serious top end!), the power delivery wasn’t to my preference, and I like the 1103 motor better (it’s like the sweet spot between the top end biased v4r and the tractor pull torque of the v2r).
And regarding the v4 “walking away” from everything, remember the start of the 2019 wsbk season - Bautista was 8 for 8 race wins over the first 4 rounds and was winning by big gaps iirc. Then the boardroom racing caught up with him and wsbk limited the v4 rev range by like 500 rpm, and Rea started winning again. Coincidence? I don’t know, but it’s an interesting correlation. Also, I have been repeatedly told by instructors on the other liter bikes (Apes, gixxers, r1’s, and kawi’s), that I leave them on the straights despite intentionally short-shifting and not going full throttle to avoid being “that guy”. During coaching sessions, they all say very matter-of-factly, “You left me on the straight - you’re on a Panigale v4.”, as if it’s a forgone conclusion. Lol
Others mileage may vary.
Edit - Mav replied while I was typing.