It's all personal preference . I was responding to a post between the 15 R and the 1299 . I raced a S1000 in 2012 it felt like a big pig to me compared to the Panigale but that's a personal preference some people love them .
precisely my feelings and experience. The BMW S1000RR without a doubt has an amazing, mind-boggling engine, it's a work of sheer genius.. The rest of the bike has some major flaws. The suspension is average, the bike weighs too much and feels every pound of its weight, the brakes are decent, but not at the level of the M50's, it steers very heavily, it needs swing arm insert height adjustments to make the geometry work and even though it has MONSTER top end, it is a bit lacking in midrange and the gearing needs a ton of tinkering to get it to work properly.
I moved to the Panigale 1299S, because it already had all the things I was going to have to change on the BMW at great expense. The one thing that has been a bit shocking to me about the 1299S, is that because of the way the engine produces torque, it is almost impossible to be I the wrong part of the rev range as it relates to gearing. At one of my local tracks, I had to change my front sprocket, rear sprocket and STILL couldn't get the hearing right for all the corner exits and for the mid corners on the BMW.. So far, the Panigale works perfectly for me, with the stock gearing.
Let's not even discuss how much lighter the Panigale feels. The differential is around 30lbs, but it feels more like 50lbs.
The BMW is an awesome bike and a fantastic all-rounder, but the Panigale 1299S has turned out to be EXACTLY what I always wanted.
Cheers.