Grayson, It has been about a year and a half since the last theft. My Aprilia was stolen November 2013 and my Panigale was stolen sunday night or Monday morning.
Just be cautious of Geico, anything under 3 years with comprehensive and it throws a red flag. While the incident isn't your fault, they will go over how the bike was stored and secured. They will a claims expert and an investigator working the case more than likely.
FYI, I dont do insurance. I have worked investigations in the past that are not insurance related.